All bakery items are subject to change on a weekly basis. Some items listed may not be available certain days. Please call if you are looking for something specific and we can inform you when we will have the item you are inquiring about available. If you would like to come in or give us a call to order special items, there is a minimum amount of 12 items for the purchase.


Please inform your server if anyone in your party has any food allergies.

Muffins* $2.50 each

Mary Beth's Peach Muffins

Brewster Blueberry Muffins

French Breakfast Muffins (cinnamon and nutmeg)

Strawberry Rhubarb Muffins

Coffeecake Muffins

Chocolate Chip Muffins

Chocolate Cream Cheese Muffins

Pumpkin, Cranberry, and Walnut Muffins

*Many muffins vary from day to day. Feel free to call and ask about special muffins.

Scones* $2.50 each

Blueberry Scones

Butter Scones

Strawberry Jam Scones

Cape Cod Cranberry Scones

Maple Pecan Scones

Lemon Poppyseed Scones

Cheddar Apple Scones

Cheddar Chive Scones

*Many scones vary from day to day. Feel free to call and ask about special scones.

Brownies* $3.75 each

Chocolate Meltaway Brownie

Chocolate Cream Cheese Brownie

Raspberry Cream Cheese Brownie

German Chocolate Brownie (coconut topping)

John's Peppermint Frosted Fudge Brownie

Brewster Brownie (peanut, caramel, and white chocolate)

Vanilla Frosted Fudge Brownie

*Call about our other in-store options.

Bars* $3.75 each

Raspberry Pecan Bars

Lemon Bars

Blueberry Crunch Bars

Peach Oatmeal Bars

Cranberry Date Bars

Peanut Butter Sinful Bars

Pumpkin Pie Square

*Bars change on a day to day basis. Please call for any questions about bars of the day.

Quiche* $19.50 each

Savory Tomato Pie

Roasted Veggie Quiche

Spinach and Sundried Tomato Quiche

Bacon, Scallion, and Cheddar Quiche

Ham and Cheddar Quiche

Ham and Broccoli Quiche

Broccoli and Cheddar Quiche

Southwestern Quiche

*Quiche is sold whole. Quiche is limited to only Saturdays during our 2 day schedule. Flavors change by week, feel free to call us with any questions.

Cookies* $1.75 each

Ben's Chocolate Chip


Molly's M n' M

Molly's Soft Sugar

Hopkins House Hermits (walnuts and raisins)

Cape Cod Hermits (walnuts and cranberries)

Kate's Peanut Butter Bears (peanut butter with a Hershey kiss and m n' ms)


Cranberry Bog (oatmeal with cranberries and white chocolate)

Amy's Almond Macaroon (GF)

Sara's Oatmeal Crisp

*For more inquiries about cookies, feel free to give us a call and ask what else we have in store.

Pies* $24 each (prices may vary)

Strawberry Rhubarb Pie

Blueberry Crunch Pie

Nectarine Blueberry Tart

Nectarine Raspberry Tart

Apple Pie

Brownie Pudding Pie

Fudge Cake

Key Lime Pie

Lemon Beach pie

*Pies are different weekly. Please call to see what we will have available each weekend.

Other Prices

Cupcakes: $3.75

Whoopie pies: $3

Tarts: $21

Cherry tart: $18

Coffee Cake (various flavors): $18

Large tomato pies: $20

Small tomato pies: $4

Gazpacho: $6

Sausage bread: $10

Pound cake: $9

*Bakery items vary daily. Please call to see what we will have available each weekend.